TL;DR
- Ukita Naoie’s fate affects both narrative progression and character relationships throughout the campaign
- Choosing ‘Finish reading’ enables the sparing option and reveals additional backstory context
- The boss battle features unique shinobi summoning mechanics requiring specific counter-strategies
- Character selection between Yasuke and Naoe significantly impacts combat approach and difficulty
- Long-term consequences include altered dialogue trees and mission availability in later chapters
GameSpot may receive revenue from affiliate and advertising partnerships for sharing this content and from purchases through links.
Facing the moral crossroads with Ukita Naoie in Assassin’s Creed Shadows presents one of the campaign’s most emotionally charged decisions. This formidable figure has managed to antagonize both a powerful regional warlord and our dual protagonists through his political machinations. The choice extends beyond mere survival, forcing players to consider how they’ll explain their actions to his young son Hideie. Be aware that this analysis contains significant spoilers regarding late-game narrative developments.
The pivotal moment determining Ukita Naoie’s survival occurs during The Noble story arc, where you must eliminate this key member of the Shinbakufu organization. This narrative segment unfolds through several interconnected missions:
Before reaching the decisive moment regarding Ukita Naoie’s fate, you must successfully navigate Himeji Castle’s heavily fortified upper levels. The concentration of elite guards throughout the complex makes stealth approaches challenging. For this segment, we strongly recommend utilizing Yasuke’s combat prowess due to his superior health pool and melee capabilities. Upon entering Naoie’s private chambers, you’ll encounter him engrossed in studying an ancient scroll, presenting two distinct interaction paths:
Ukita Naoie presents a moderately challenging combat encounter when faced directly. His individual attack patterns are relatively predictable, but the battle complexity increases dramatically when he deploys smoke bombs to summon shinobi reinforcements. These additional combatants require immediate attention to prevent being overwhelmed. Success demands aggressive engagement using your most powerful abilities and equipment. Your character selection dramatically influences combat dynamics, making proper skill optimization essential. Consult our Class Guide for detailed ability synergies that can turn the battle in your favor.
The ramifications of your decision extend throughout the remaining narrative, affecting character relationships and available mission paths. Eliminating Naoie provides immediate resolution but closes certain diplomatic options in later chapters. Sparing him introduces narrative complexity and potential alliances that wouldn’t otherwise develop. Consider how each outcome aligns with your character’s moral compass and strategic objectives for the region.
Action Checklist
- Complete all Harima region preparatory missions including the poetry competition and weapons cache recovery
- Rescue Hideie from Itatehyozu Shrine to trigger the Naoie revelation
- Infiltrate Himeji Castle using Yasuke for optimal combat performance
- Select ‘Finish reading’ dialogue option to preserve sparing possibility
- Employ aggressive tactics during boss battle while managing shinobi reinforcements
- Make final decision based on desired narrative outcomes and character alignment
No reproduction without permission：SeeYouSoon Game Club » Should You Kill Or Spare Ukita Naoie Assassin’s Creed Shadows Strategic guide for Ukita Naoie decision in Assassin's Creed Shadows with combat tactics and consequences analysis