MLB The Show 23 Best Players – Ranking The Top 10

MLB The Show 23 delivers the most comprehensive baseball simulation experience yet, featuring updated rosters and refined player ratings that mirror real-world performance. Understanding these ratings is crucial for building championship-caliber teams and maximizing your gameplay advantage.

The rating system in MLB The Show 23 evaluates players across multiple attributes including contact, power, fielding, and pitching metrics. This year’s edition showcases four exceptional athletes who have reached the pinnacle 99 Overall rating, representing the absolute best in professional baseball. The following analysis covers the ten highest-rated players, ranked by their Overall Rating score.

10. Bryce Harper – 95 Overall – Philadelphia Phillies

Bryce Harper occupies the tenth position as the Philadelphia Phillies’ primary outfielder and designated hitter. Despite playing through injuries during the previous campaign, Harper maintains his status as one of baseball’s most dangerous offensive threats, backed by his MVP credentials. His impressive 95 Overall stems from exceptional right-handed attributes: 94 Contact R and 98 Power R, complemented by solid 80 Arm strength for outfield defense.

9. Max Scherzer – 96 Overall – New York Mets

New York Mets ace Max Scherzer claims the ninth spot with his 96 Overall evaluation. The three-time Cy Young Award recipient demonstrated his continued dominance through 23 starts in 2022, recording 11 victories against 5 losses with a stellar 2.29 ERA. Within MLB The Show 23, Scherzer’s arsenal includes 99 Break on his pitches, 92 Stamina for deep outings, and 89 H/9 limiting opponent hitting success.

8. Paul Goldschmidt – 96 Overall – St. Louis Cardinals

Reigning National League MVP Paul Goldschmidt represents the St. Louis Cardinals at eighth position with his 96 Overall. Goldschmidt earned his MVP honors through a spectacular .317 batting average, 35 home runs, and 115 RBIs, driving his team to division supremacy and postseason contention. His in-game attributes feature perfect 99 Power L and 99 Contact L against right-handed pitching, with 84 Contact R and 73 Reaction time.

7. Corbin Burnes – 96 Overall – Milwaukee Brewers

Milwaukee Brewers starting pitcher Corbin Burnes secures seventh place with identical 96 Overall marks. The former Cy Young winner appeared in 33 contests during 2022, achieving 12 wins, 8 losses, and a 2.94 ERA. Burnes’ digital representation boasts 99 Velocity on his fastball, 90 Stamina, 88 H/9, and 86 Break on his secondary offerings.

6. Mookie Betts – 97 Overall – Los Angeles Dodgers

Los Angeles Dodgers right fielder Mookie Betts captures sixth position with his 97 Overall rating. Recognized for his Gold Glove-caliber defense, Betts also delivers substantial offensive production, batting .269 with 35 homers and 82 RBIs last season. His well-rounded skill set translates to 89 Power L, 85 Power R, 88 Fielding, and 81 Vision attributes within the game.

5. Justin Verlander – 98 Overall – New York Mets

Justin Verlander continues to defy age with elite performance, now featuring for the New York Mets with a 98 Overall. The three-time Cy Young winner, including his 2022 American League recognition, dominated through 28 appearances, securing 18 wins against 4 losses with a microscopic 1.75 ERA, contributing significantly to Houston’s World Series championship.

Three-time Cy Young winner Justin Verlander now plays for the New York Mets.

Verlander’s in-game attributes reflect his real-world excellence: 94 H/9, 93 Stamina, 90 Break, and 89 BB/9 for exceptional control.

4. Jacob deGrom – 99 Overall – Texas Rangers

Two-time Cy Young recipient Jacob deGrom transitions to the Texas Rangers while maintaining his 99 Overall status. Despite injury limitations restricting him to 11 starts in 2022, deGrom remained dominant when available, recording 5 wins, 4 losses, and a 3.08 ERA with 102 strikeouts across 64.1 innings. His digital profile features maximum 99 Velocity, 96 H/9, 96 K/9, and 90 BB/9 ratings.

3. Mike Trout – 99 Overall – Los Angeles Angels

Mike Trout maintains his position among baseball’s elite with a 99 Overall rating for the Los Angeles Angels. When healthy, Trout demonstrates why he’s considered a generational talent with exceptional five-tool capabilities. His balanced attributes make him valuable both offensively and defensively, with particular strength in power hitting and base running.

2. Shohei Ohtani – 99 Overall – Los Angeles Angels

Shohei Ohtani revolutionizes the game as both an elite hitter and dominant pitcher, earning his 99 Overall. The two-way phenomenon continues to achieve historic milestones, making him arguably the most unique and valuable player in modern baseball history.

1. Aaron Judge – 99 Overall – New York Yankees

Aaron Judge claims the top position with his 99 Overall following a record-breaking 62-home run season. The American League MVP combines massive power with surprisingly agile defense and solid contact skills, making him the complete package in MLB The Show 23.

Building a competitive roster requires strategic consideration beyond simply collecting the highest-rated players. Balance your lineup with both left and right-handed power, ensure defensive reliability at key positions, and develop a pitching rotation with varied styles to keep opponents off-balance.

Common Team-Building Mistakes to Avoid: Overloading on one position type, neglecting bench depth, and ignoring platoon advantages can undermine even the most talented rosters. Instead, focus on creating complementary player combinations that cover various gameplay scenarios.

For advanced optimization, consider how player attributes interact during specific situations. Power hitters perform best when paired with high-contact batters who can get on base, while strikeout pitchers need strong defensive support behind them.

No reproduction without permission：SeeYouSoon Game Club » MLB The Show 23 Best Players – Ranking The Top 10 Complete breakdown of MLB The Show 23's elite players with strategic gameplay insights and team-building advice