TL;DR
- Three distinct murder scenes contain map pieces leading to the killer’s hideout
- Environmental markers like circling vultures and blood trails signal nearby crime scenes
- Map zoom functionality reveals corpse locations once you’re within detection range
- The Valentine location requires precise railroad track navigation south of town
- Scarlett Meadows victim is suspended from a tree near key road intersections
Red Dead Redemption 2’s PC release brings enhanced graphics to its already immersive open world, where players encounter numerous disturbing discoveries. Among these chance encounters, the American Dreams serial killer investigation stands out as particularly gruesome. Once you stumble upon the initial crime scene, you’ll become consumed with tracking down this deranged murderer across the frontier.
Most players discover the first victim early in their adventure, while the subsequent murder sites require longer journeys from starting zones. This guide maintains minimal location spoilers, using screenshots from early game saves to preserve your detective experience while providing crucial navigation assistance. Be aware that complete details about the American Dreams Stranger Mission are discussed ahead.
For additional assistance, explore our comprehensive guides covering essential beginner tips and hidden game mechanics. We also provide specialized resources on wealth accumulation and firearm modification to enhance your outlaw capabilities. Don’t miss our detailed Red Dead 2 analysis, and for additional entertainment, investigate our compilation of the game’s cheat codes.
Red Dead Redemption 2 News
The investigation involves three separate homicide locations, each concealing a segment of the killer’s map. To activate the full Stranger Mission narrative, you must reassemble the complete cartographic evidence. Successful crime scene detection relies on recognizing anomalous environmental features—fresh bloodstains along trails, concentrated bird activity, or unusual structural alterations. When approaching potential sites, utilize your map’s zoom feature, as it will display an X marking the victim’s position once you’re within proximity.
The initial crime scene resides immediately south of Valentine along the railway corridor. Travel directly southward following the iron tracks, navigating across a structural gap that requires precise rail riding. Beneath the subsequent overpass, you’ll discover the mutilated remains. The crime scene orientation faces westward, featuring disturbing painted messages on the right side and the victim’s decapitated head affixed to a support column on the left. The inaugural map fragment rests within the deceased’s mouth.


The second homicide location lies within Scarlett Meadows territory, requiring substantial southeast travel from Valentine. Positioned west of Shady Belle and slightly south of Rhodes, the optimal approach originates from Shady Belle—travel westward, maintain course at the initial junction, continue forward until reaching the subsequent major fork. Execute a right turn here, proceeding straight until encountering another road division. The corpse hangs suspended from a substantial tree on your left; map coordinates align approximately with the “S” in “meadows.” Circumnavigate the tree’s rear to locate the severed cranium and accompanying map segment.
Seasoned investigators should consider weather patterns and temporal factors—rain obscures blood trails while nighttime exploration heightens tension but reduces visibility. Common errors include premature departure from areas before the map marker appears; ensure thorough perimeter searches within 50-meter radii of suspected locations. For optimal efficiency, combine this investigation with other regional activities to minimize backtracking across the expansive map terrain.
Action Checklist
- Survey Valentine’s southern railroad tracks for blood evidence and circling vultures
- Navigate precisely across the railway gap to locate the underpass crime scene
- Collect map fragment from victim’s mouth and document environmental clues
- Travel southeast to Scarlett Meadows, using road forks as navigation markers
- Examine large trees near the ‘S’ in meadows for suspended victim
No reproduction without permission:SeeYouSoon Game Club » Where To Find Red Dead 2’s Gruesome Serial Killer Side Mission Master the American Dreams serial killer hunt with expert location strategies and evidence collection techniques
