Thiago Silva criticizes EA FC 24 player ratings system and explains how football game ratings work
The Rating Controversy Explained
Veteran defender Thiago Silva expressed significant disappointment upon discovering his reduced EA SPORTS FC 24 rating, directly challenging the evaluation methods used by the game developers.
Chelsea’s experienced center back Thiago Silva questioned EA Sports’ match observation practices after learning about his downgraded rating in the forthcoming EA FC 24 release.
This year represents a monumental shift for Electronic Arts’ football simulation series, transitioning from the long-standing FIFA partnership to the newly branded EA Sports FC platform.
Despite this branding evolution, core gameplay mechanics and popular modes will maintain continuity, preserving the familiar experience that dedicated players have come to appreciate throughout the series’ history.
The rating adjustment has already generated controversy within professional football circles, with Silva publicly voicing his dissatisfaction regarding the perceived inaccuracy of his player assessment.
During an interview with the Premier League’s official YouTube platform, the 38-year-old Brazilian defender anticipated maintaining his previous rating level, only to receive the unexpected news of a two-point reduction.
His statistical evaluation decreased from 86 in FIFA 23 to 84 in EA FC 24, representing a significant downgrade that surprised both the player and his supporters.
Understanding EA FC Player Rating Systems
Silva humorously demonstrated his frustration by covering his eyes while commenting “They’re not watching any matches!” suggesting the rating team operates without proper match analysis.
The Brazilian international provided specific feedback, noting “Certainly my offensive contributions need enhancement, as I failed to score throughout last season. This coming year I believe I can boost my attacking statistics, though my defensive capabilities remain strong.”
At thirty-eight years old, Silva has remarkably maintained elite physical condition well beyond typical professional football career spans, yet the rating decrease frustrated him despite his age-defying performances and Chelsea’s challenging previous campaign.
Understanding EA’s rating methodology reveals that player evaluations combine multiple data points including match performance statistics, physical attributes, team success metrics, and positional specialization. The system weighs recent form heavily while also considering long-term consistency and potential decline patterns for veteran players.
For defenders like Silva, key rating factors include tackle success rates, interception numbers, clearance efficiency, aerial duel percentages, and passing accuracy. While Silva maintained strong defensive metrics, his lack of offensive contributions and Chelsea’s overall defensive record likely influenced the rating adjustment.
The age factor in EA’s algorithm typically applies gradual reductions for players over 32, though exceptional performers can maintain ratings through consistent high-level displays. Silva’s case highlights the tension between statistical algorithms and subjective performance quality assessment.
Practical Tips for Managing Player Ratings
Strategic squad building requires understanding rating fluctuation patterns. Players facing rating decreases often represent value opportunities in Ultimate Team modes, as their cards become more affordable while maintaining similar in-game performance.
Monitor player form in real-world matches closely, as strong performances frequently trigger rating upgrades through in-form cards and potential rating revisions in subsequent game updates. Setting alerts for players showing improved form can help capitalize on market inefficiencies.
When building defensive lines, prioritize chemistry links and complementary skill sets over individual overall ratings. A rated 84 defender with perfect chemistry and suitable work rates often outperforms a rated 86 player with poor chemistry connections.
For veteran players like Silva, consider their specific attributes rather than overall rating. His positioning (85), interceptions (86), and defensive awareness (87) remain elite-level despite the overall rating reduction, making him valuable in specific tactical setups.
Track performance in key statistical categories that influence future rating updates. For defenders, focus on clean sheet contributions, successful tackle percentages, and pass completion rates in their own half—these metrics heavily impact defensive rating components.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
Avoid overemphasizing overall ratings when building squads. Many players fixate on the single overall number while missing more important attribute distributions and chemistry implications that determine actual in-game effectiveness.
Don’t ignore age-related rating declines without context. While older players typically receive rating reductions, many maintain exceptional key attributes that make them valuable budget options, especially in career mode and early Ultimate Team stages.
Resist making immediate player sales after rating decreases. The market often overreacts to rating changes, creating buying opportunities. Wait for the initial panic selling to subside before making transfer decisions involving downgraded players.
Never underestimate the impact of specialized attributes. Silva’s defensive mental attributes (positioning, interceptions, defensive awareness) remain among the Premier League’s best, making him effective despite the overall rating reduction.
EA Sports FC 26 review – The best football game in years
Huge EA FC 26 ratings leak crowns Mo Salah & Mbappe as world’s best players
Best EA FC 25 formations & tactics to dominate Ultimate Team
The upcoming season will reveal whether Silva can enhance his offensive contributions and participate more actively in goal-scoring opportunities.
No reproduction without permission：SeeYouSoon Game Club » Thiago Silva says EA “don’t watch football” after seeing his EA FC 24 rating Thiago Silva criticizes EA FC 24 player ratings system and explains how football game ratings work