Starfield Shattered Space – Which Brother Should You Tranquilize In The Duel?

Starfield’s Shattered Space DLC presents players with a compelling moral dilemma through The Duel side quest, where your decisions directly shape the fate of three siblings. This narrative-rich mission becomes accessible early in your journey through the expansion content.

The quest initiation occurs in Dazra’s main courtyard, Va’ruun’kai’s sacred capital city. Here, you’ll overhear a tense exchange between Amila, Borhal, and Danika – siblings embroiled in a family crisis. The confrontation stems from Amila’s desecration of their mother’s funeral urn, an act that triggers Borhal’s challenge to settle their dispute through combat.

Danika serves as the voice of reason throughout this emotional turmoil, seeking your assistance to mediate between her warring brothers. Understanding these character dynamics is crucial for navigating the quest’s complex decision matrix effectively.

Despite extensive dialogue options and persuasion attempts, stopping the duel entirely proves impossible within Starfield’s narrative design. The brothers’ deeply entrenched positions create an inevitable path toward confrontation that players must navigate rather than prevent.

Borhal’s motivation extends beyond mere revenge for the urn desecration; he reveals that Amila has “had this coming for a while,” indicating longstanding family tensions. Meanwhile, Amila’s pride prevents him from offering genuine apologies, locking both characters into their destructive trajectory.

The confrontation’s inevitability becomes apparent through failed mediation attempts.

Every dialogue path, including direct pleas for reconciliation, results in both brothers insisting on proceeding with their lethal duel. This design choice reinforces the quest’s theme of influencing outcomes rather than preventing conflicts, similar to strategic decisions in our BF6 Class Selection Guide where player choice shapes battlefield dynamics.

When verbal mediation fails, Danika devises an alternative strategy involving tranquilizing the ceremonial drinks consumed before the duel. This approach shifts the conflict from prevention to controlled outcome management.

At the quest marker location, you’ll encounter four distinct intervention options, each producing dramatically different narrative outcomes:

• Tranquilize Amila: Borhal interprets his brother’s incapacitation as feigned illness and executes him regardless. (Rewards: 5,000 Credits and XP)
• Tranquilize Borhal: Amila shows no mercy toward his apparently ill brother and proceeds with the killing. (Rewards: 5,000 Credits and XP)
• Tranquilize Both: This neutral option prevents either death but may impact future family interactions.
• Tranquilize Nobody: Allowing the duel to proceed naturally reveals additional character dialogue and combat sequences.

Strategic positioning during the tranquilizer application phase.

Notably, the first two options provide identical reward packages, suggesting the game emphasizes narrative consequence over gameplay advantage. This reward structure mirrors the balanced approach found in our BF6 Weapons Unlock Guide where different paths yield equivalent progression benefits.

Seasoned players should approach The Duel with strategic preparation, similar to optimizing loadouts in our Battlefield 6 Complete Guide strategies. Save before the tranquilizer decision point to experience multiple outcomes without replaying extensive sections.

A common mistake involves underestimating the brothers’ determination; no amount of persuasion skill investment will prevent the duel itself. Instead, focus resources on combat preparation or dialogue options that reveal additional backstory context.

The quest’s moral complexity extends beyond immediate outcomes, potentially influencing future interactions with Va’ruun faction members. Your choice may resonate through subsequent DLC content, making this more than an isolated moral decision.

For players seeking optimal efficiency, the tranquilizer application requires approximately 5-7 minutes from quest acceptance to completion. This timeframe assumes efficient navigation and minimal additional exploration during the mission sequence.

No reproduction without permission：SeeYouSoon Game Club » Starfield Shattered Space – Which Brother Should You Tranquilize In The Duel? Master Starfield's Duel quest with strategic outcomes, tranquilizer tactics, and moral decision-making insights