Analyzing the prolonged Shadow of the Erdtree DLC wait and whether FromSoftware should prioritize Elden Ring 2 development instead
The Extended Wait for Shadow of the Erdtree
As Elden Ring nears its second anniversary, the extended development cycle for Shadow of the Erdtree raises fundamental questions about expansion strategy versus sequel development priorities.
Back in 2022, few could have predicted we’d still be anticipating Elden Ring’s expansion in 2024. The prolonged timeline has surprised even the most dedicated fans, creating an unusual situation in the gaming landscape.
What makes this delay particularly noteworthy is Elden Ring’s initial market dominance, where it overshadowed other major releases like Horizon Forbidden West. The contrast between that explosive launch and the subsequent two-year expansion wait creates significant narrative tension for the community.
FromSoftware’s groundbreaking open-world design represented a genre evolution, building upon their Souls series foundation. While initial patience was understandable, the extended timeline has tested even the most optimistic expectations.
The situation increasingly resembles the long-anticipated novel The Winds of Winter from George R.R. Martin’s A Song of Ice and Fire series. Though Martin’s involvement in Elden Ring’s lore creation is coincidental, the parallel development timelines create unavoidable comparisons between these beloved fantasy universes.
Strategic Preparation Tip: Veteran players recommend maintaining multiple character saves at different progression points to accommodate potential DLC level requirements. This ensures you can experience the expansion content at appropriate difficulty levels regardless of when it releases.
The Elden Ring 2 Possibility
The extended Shadow of the Erdtree development timeline naturally raises questions about potential redirection toward Elden Ring 2. With FromSoftware likely working on both projects simultaneously, the calculus changes as development timelines extend.
Historical industry precedents provide relevant context. The transformation of Final Fantasy Versus XIII into Final Fantasy XV demonstrates how extended development can lead to strategic project reevaluation. What began as a spin-off evolved into a mainline entry when development realities shifted.
This evolution proved beneficial overall. Despite some criticism, Final Fantasy XV achieved broader recognition than other Fabula Nova Crystallis titles. This success story raises legitimate questions about whether similar strategic shifts could benefit Elden Ring’s future.
Examining FromSoftware’s development patterns reveals interesting timing. The two-year gap between Dark Souls 2 and Dark Souls 3 included DLC releases and Bloodborne’s development, suggesting the studio can manage multiple major projects simultaneously.
YouTuber announces Elden Ring lore book set to span over 400 pages
Everything we know about Elden Ring Nightreign
Elden Ring movie may get made without George R.R. Martin but there’s a good reason
Common Mistake to Avoid: Don’t assume separate development teams guarantee timely releases. Resource sharing between projects often creates bottlenecks, especially with specialized talent like environment designers and combat system programmers.
Even if Shadow of the Erdtree doesn’t surprise release on the anniversary date, FromSoftware has already exceeded its typical expansion development cycle. However, Elden Ring’s ambitious scope compared to previous Souls titles justifies some timeline extension.
Strategic Decision Factors
Shadow of the Erdtree likely represents the most expansive Souls game addition to date, explaining the extended development period. However, strategic considerations extend beyond mere content scale.
While separate development teams probably handle DLC and sequel development, resource consolidation could accelerate Elden Ring 2’s timeline. If DLC development extends beyond two years, the business case for redirecting resources strengthens considerably.
The longer the wait continues, the more plausible standalone expansion or sequel integration becomes. Another year without release would make this scenario increasingly likely. Elden Ring 2 represents an inevitable development priority for publisher Bandai Namco.
Creative works ultimately release when ready, and this analysis isn’t intended to pressure developers. However, publisher priorities and market realities inevitably influence development direction over extended timelines.
We anticipate returning to the Lands Between aboard Torrent regardless of the release format. If Shadow of the Erdtree emerges under different branding, the community will likely adapt accordingly.
Optimization Strategy: Advanced players should focus on completing all achievement-based content and exploring hidden areas that might connect to DLC storylines. This ensures maximum continuity regardless of how content eventually releases.
Current assessment suggests Shadow of the Erdtree remains too developed for complete retooling into Elden Ring 2. Release timing likely approaches, though the expansion’s development shadow looms large.
Practical Player Implications
If the anniversary passes without announcement, players should consider strategic adjustments to their expectations and preparation.
The community faces several practical considerations during this extended wait period. Understanding development realities helps manage expectations while maintaining excitement for future content.
Community Engagement Tip: Participate in lore discussion communities and theory-crafting sessions. These activities maintain engagement during development gaps and might provide insights into potential DLC storyline directions.
Players should balance preparation with flexibility. While specific character builds might optimize DLC enjoyment, maintaining adaptable playstyles ensures enjoyment regardless of final content format.
The extended timeline also provides opportunity to experience other FromSoftware titles, gaining broader perspective on the developer’s evolution and potential direction for future Elden Ring content.
Elden Ring multiplayer | Elden Ring character classes | Elden Ring character creator | Elden Ring New Game Plus | Survive an invasion in Elden Ring | How to level up in Elden Ring | How to get the Horse in Elden Ring
No reproduction without permission：SeeYouSoon Game Club » Shadow of the Erdtree: Should FromSoftware just make it Elden Ring 2? Analyzing the prolonged Shadow of the Erdtree DLC wait and whether FromSoftware should prioritize Elden Ring 2 development instead