MLB The Show 24 Player Ratings: The 11 Best Players In The Game

GameSpot may receive revenue from affiliate and advertising partnerships for sharing this content and from purchases through links.

MLB The Show 24 introduces significant enhancements to the acclaimed baseball simulation franchise, featuring comprehensive roster revisions and refined player evaluations. The rating system now includes just five athletes achieving the prestigious 99 overall designation, complemented by six additional players rated 95 or above. These elite ratings reflect real-world performance metrics and projected impact for the upcoming season.

The latest installment expands narrative experiences with Storylines mode, building upon last year’s foundation. This edition incorporates historically significant content spotlighting Negro League pioneers, including Toni Stone—the first female professional baseball athlete. Additionally, Road to the Show: Pave Their Way enables creation of female protagonists navigating professional baseball careers, offering fresh perspectives on the sport.

Despite no longer partnering with Shohei Ohtani following his Dodgers transition, Mike Trout maintains his three-time MVP caliber. The Angels center fielder’s defensive excellence and superior hitting capabilities remain intact, though injury management becomes crucial for maximizing his contributions. Strategic resting periods between games can preserve his performance levels throughout extended seasons.

Aaron Judge’s impressive power hitting continues despite limited playing time, launching 37 home runs last season. The Yankees’ formidable right fielder previously established the American League single-season home run record at 62, earning both Rookie of the Year and MVP honors. His towering 6’7″ frame generates exceptional plate coverage and raw power that translates perfectly to gameplay mechanics.

Shohei Ohtani’s monumental $700 million decade-long Dodgers contract secures baseball’s premier two-way talent. While real-world pitching limitations exist due to injury recovery, MLB The Show 24 preserves his unique dual-threat capabilities. Understanding when to deploy him as hitter versus pitcher becomes a strategic decision that can determine game outcomes.

Mookie Betts transitions to second base while maintaining elite offensive production, having delivered 39 home runs with a .309 batting average. Position flexibility adds significant roster construction value, allowing managers to optimize defensive alignments while retaining offensive firepower.

Ronald Acuña Jr.’s historic 70/40 club membership—73 stolen bases with 41 home runs—earned him National League MVP honors. His exceptional combination of speed and power, complemented by 106 RBIs and .337 batting average, creates a multidimensional threat few players can match.

Corey Seager’s instrumental role in securing Texas Rangers’ inaugural World Series championship earned him a second World Series MVP award. The shortstop’s 33 home runs and 96 RBIs came despite early-season absences, demonstrating his clutch performance capabilities in critical moments.

Spencer Strider’s dominant pitching arsenal, highlighted by explosive fastball velocity and remarkable strikeout proficiency, justifies his 97 rating. His 20-5 record with 3.86 ERA and astounding 281 strikeouts across 186.2 innings establishes him as a rotation cornerstone. Advanced players should monitor his pitch count to maintain effectiveness through later innings.

Additional elite performers include Austin Riley (96), Matt Olson (95), Yordan Álvarez (96), and Gerrit Cole (95), providing depth beyond the top-tier ratings. These players often represent exceptional value in franchise mode drafts and can be acquired at more reasonable costs than 99-rated counterparts while delivering nearly equivalent production.

Constructing championship-caliber rosters requires understanding nuanced player attributes beyond surface-level overall ratings. Defensive positioning, platoon advantages, and stamina management often determine success more than raw talent alone. For those mastering Complete Guide strategies in other sports titles, similar systematic approaches apply here.

Common strategic errors include overvaluing overall ratings while ignoring specific skill sets needed for ballpark configurations. For example, power hitters gain disproportionate value in smaller venues, while contact specialists excel in larger stadiums. Positional flexibility, as demonstrated by Mookie Betts’ transition, provides managers with crucial lineup versatility.

Advanced optimization involves studying individual player tendencies and leveraging ballpark factors to maximize performance. Much like optimizing Weapons Unlock paths in shooters, developing specialized player roles creates competitive advantages. Pitcher-hitter matchups, defensive shifts, and bullpen management mirror the tactical depth found in comprehensive Class Guide systems from other gaming genres.

Effective roster management balances star power with cost-controlled talent, particularly in franchise modes with salary cap constraints. Monitoring player development trajectories and identifying breakout candidates before they achieve premium ratings can establish long-term dominance.

No reproduction without permission：SeeYouSoon Game Club » MLB The Show 24 Player Ratings: The 11 Best Players In The Game Complete guide to MLB The Show 24's elite players, new features, and strategic gameplay insights