Why Souls veterans struggle with Lies of P’s unique combat systems and how to overcome its difficulty walls
The Unexpected Wall for Souls Veterans
Lies of P delivers an unexpectedly formidable challenge that has proven overwhelming even for players with extensive Dark Souls completion experience.
While players anticipated Lies of P would present difficulty, the reality has shocked the community with veteran Dark Souls enthusiasts reporting hitting progression barriers unlike anything encountered in FromSoftware titles, leading some to abandon the game entirely despite their proven track record with similar games.
Bloodborne created enduring anticipation within its fanbase, with any potential sequel news generating extensive discussion among eager followers, making Lies of P appear positioned to satisfy that specific Souls-like craving for FromSoftware devotees.
However, players who successfully conquered the most demanding encounters across Souls games and other FromSoft productions have encountered an entirely different caliber of obstacle in Lies of P.
Numerous reports indicate boss encounters requiring dozens of hours to overcome, with some players opting to discontinue their playthroughs completely, creating widespread sentiment that Lies of P exceeds the difficulty threshold of its inspirational predecessors.
How Lies of P Differs from FromSoftware Classics
The original Dark Souls launch fundamentally transformed gaming standards, establishing a benchmark against which numerous subsequent titles would be measured. When discussions revolve around game difficulty, Dark Souls inevitably enters the conversation rapidly.
Despite the somewhat repetitive nature of constantly comparing game challenges to Dark Souls, Lies of P’s proximity to its inspiration makes such comparisons unavoidable.
For countless Souls enthusiasts, Lies of P presents substantially greater difficulty than the Souls series itself.
Discussions ignited immediately following release, highlighted by one player’s divisive post detailing how they completed every Souls game multiple times yet found themselves unable to advance in Lies of P.
Additional players reported becoming immobilized by specific boss encounters for periods exceeding twelve continuous hours.
With adversaries regenerating health during extended periods without player contact and severely restricted long-distance combat alternatives, gamers must fully utilize every available game system rather than discovering personalized victory approaches. Players who completed titles like Elden Ring primarily through magical means find themselves critically underprepared for Lies of P’s demands.
Megabonk’s new Spooky Update is so hard players are threatening to quit
Hollow Knight: Silksong speedrunners are already beating it in under 90 minutes
Lies of P best builds for all playstyles
Professional Perspective: Embracing the Game’s Design
This situation has prompted substantial criticism from Souls players targeting Lies of P, insisting the game requires comprehensive revisions to fundamental systems including parrying mechanics, evasion techniques, and other combat essentials to better align with FromSoftware conventions.
Nevertheless, Souls specialist Iron Pineapple contended that, while acknowledging player frustrations as valid, individuals must relinquish predetermined expectations regarding the game’s “appropriate” design in exchange for accepting Lies of P according to its actual nature.
“This game demonstrates evident meticulous design intention, with decisions such as non-cancellable attack animations or comparatively narrow parry windows representing deliberate design choices rather than oversights or errors. They simply diverge from what many players have grown accustomed to.”
He elaborated further, “The collective reaction strongly resembles the initial response to Sekiro’s debut, along with similar reactions to the Nioh series releases, where players disengage because they approached them as Souls titles. Certain individuals play it assuming it’s Bloodborne, others treat it as Sekiro. Both perspectives are mistaken. You must approach it as Lies of P specifically and engage with the game according to its own parameters.”
Overcoming the Challenge: Practical Tips and Techniques
Success in Lies of P requires a fundamental mindset shift from traditional Souls gameplay approaches. The game demands precision and system mastery rather than brute force persistence.
Master the Parry System: Unlike Souls games where dodging often suffices, Lies of P requires precise parry timing. Practice against early enemies to internalize the rhythm – the window is tighter but delivers significant rewards when mastered.
Aggressive Positioning: The health regeneration mechanic punishes passive play. Maintain constant pressure and learn enemy attack patterns to identify safe engagement windows rather than retreating to heal.
Weapon Assembly Understanding: The game’s unique weapon assembly system allows customization that can dramatically alter difficulty. Experiment with different blade and handle combinations to find what works against specific enemy types.
Legion Arm Utilization: Many players overlook the Legion Arm’s strategic potential. Different arms provide solutions to various combat scenarios – the Puppet String offers mobility while Fulminis can interrupt enemy attacks.
Learn Animation Commitments: Attacks cannot be cancelled mid-animation, requiring deliberate decision-making. Study enemy movements and only commit to attacks when you’re confident they’ll connect.
Common mistakes include approaching combat with Souls muscle memory, underestimating the importance of perfect guards, and neglecting the game’s unique mechanics. Advanced players recommend focusing on learning two or three key techniques thoroughly rather than attempting to master everything simultaneously.
No reproduction without permission：SeeYouSoon Game Club » Lies of P called ‘hardest game ever’ as Souls vets hit difficulty wall Why Souls veterans struggle with Lies of P's unique combat systems and how to overcome its difficulty walls