How Honkai Star Rail players want Genshin Impact’s crafting bonus system to solve frustrating material farming
Introduction: The Farming Frustration
Honkai Star Rail’s dedicated player base has reached a breaking point with what they describe as excessively punishing material farming systems, sparking widespread calls for quality-of-life improvements borrowed from Genshin Impact.
The community’s frustration centers on disappointing drop rates for critical upgrade materials, with many players labeling the current Honkai Star Rail system “a pain in the ass” compared to Genshin Impact’s more forgiving mechanics.
While gacha games like Honkai Star Rail and Genshin Impact deliver exceptional entertainment through diverse characters, compelling narratives, and engaging events, their progression systems often necessitate extensive grinding for essential resources. This farming requirement represents a core tension between player satisfaction and game longevity that developers must carefully balance.
A recent Reddit post showcasing particularly poor farming results ignited this discussion, with the original poster displaying their meager haul despite investing significant resources. The community response was immediate and overwhelming, with dozens of comments echoing the frustration and explicitly requesting that Honkai Star Rail adopt specific quality-of-life features currently exclusive to Genshin Impact.
Why Trace Material Farming Feels So Bad
Maximizing character Trace capabilities in the late game demands staggering quantities of materials, creating situations where players can exhaust their entire Trailblaze Powder reserve while still failing to complete even a single upgrade node. This resource-to-progress ratio feels particularly punishing compared to earlier game stages.
The problem compounds because identical Trace materials serve dual purposes—they’re essential not only for character Trace upgrades but also for enhancing Light Cones, effectively doubling their demand without increasing their availability. As players approach maximum level, securing sufficient materials transforms from a manageable grind into what many describe as a “tall order” that gates meaningful progression.
“The current drop rates feel disproportionately low considering the 60 Trailblaze Powder investment at maximum difficulty,” explained the original poster while sharing their disappointing results on Reddit. Their showcased rewards proved exceptionally lackluster, with the notable absence of any 4-star purple Trace materials despite optimal farming conditions—a scenario that statistically should occur regularly but often doesn’t in practice.
Genshin Impact devs reveal new game “Varsapura” with huge gameplay demo
Every Honkai Star Rail character’s age & height
How many people play Genshin Impact? Player count tracker in 2025
Genshin Impact’s Crafting Bonus System
The comment section quickly reached consensus, with numerous players identifying Trace material acquisition as “exceptionally frustrating to farm consistently.” This shared frustration created fertile ground for proposing concrete solutions from HoYoverse’s other major title.
Veterans of both Honkai Star Rail and Genshin Impact proposed a specific transferable feature: Genshin’s crafting bonus system. This mechanic provides a percentage chance to receive either material refunds or doubled output when processing resources, effectively increasing yield without adjusting base drop rates. “Implementing this feature in Honkai Star Rail would make marginally rewarding farming sessions substantially more tolerable,” argued one dual-game player.
Another commenter expressed nostalgia for “Genshin’s character-specific crafting passives,” which grant particular characters enhanced probabilities for bonus outputs when crafting specific material types. These passives create meaningful character utility beyond combat and encourage strategic roster consideration for resource management optimization.
The proposed system wouldn’t eliminate farming but would incorporate variance that occasionally rewards players with windfalls, transforming psychologically punishing grind sessions into potentially exciting resource-gathering opportunities with positive variance.
Community Debate: QoL vs. Game Longevity
While the majority supported implementing Genshin-style quality-of-life improvements, dissenting voices presented thoughtful counterarguments about game design philosophy. Some players consider the current drop rates “manageable rather than oppressive,” suggesting that resource scarcity intentionally regulates progression pacing.
“Accelerated material acquisition could undermine long-term engagement,” cautioned one commenter, explaining that “completing all character builds within three months might reduce retention by eliminating meaningful progression goals.” This perspective highlights the delicate balance developers must maintain between player satisfaction and sustained engagement metrics.
Middle-ground proposals emerged suggesting tiered implementations—perhaps introducing crafting bonuses only after reaching certain progression milestones or limiting their application to specific material types. Others recommended implementing the system temporarily during catch-up events for returning players while maintaining stricter economies for current endgame content.
Ultimately, most agree that expending significant effort for minimal rewards represents the pinnacle of gaming frustration. Borrowing Genshin Impact’s proven quality-of-life design could alleviate this pain point while preserving Honkai Star Rail’s distinctive progression identity through careful, customized implementation.
Optimizing Your Current Farming Strategy
Efficiency Tips While Waiting for Improvements
Until HoYoverse potentially implements quality-of-life changes, maximize your farming efficiency with these strategies:
1. Target Farming Windows: Coordinate your farming with daily reset cycles and weekly reward periods. Some players report marginally better yields during specific time windows, though this may be confirmation bias.
2. Resource Prioritization: Focus on characters who provide the greatest combat power increase per material invested. Support characters often require fewer Trace upgrades to remain effective compared to main damage dealers.
3. Light Cone Strategy: Since Trace materials pull double duty, decide whether to prioritize character Traces or Light Cone upgrades based on which provides greater immediate team improvement.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
Over-investing Early: Don’t max every Trace immediately. Many characters function effectively at 6-8/10 key Traces, saving materials for broader roster development.
Ignoring Event Shops: Limited-time events often offer Trace materials at better exchange rates than standard farming. Always check event shops before spending Trailblaze Powder.
Farming Without Goals: Always farm with specific upgrade targets in mind. Stockpiling materials “just in case” often leads to inefficient resource allocation.
Advanced Optimization for Veteran Players
Mathematical Planning: Calculate exact material needs for your next 2-3 character upgrades. This prevents overspending on one character while neglecting others.
Energy Efficiency: Track your yield per 60 Trailblaze Powder over multiple sessions. If certain stages consistently underperform, consider temporarily shifting focus.
Community Tracking: Participate in community drop rate tracking. While individual experience varies, aggregate data helps identify genuinely problematic stages versus statistical anomalies.
No reproduction without permission：SeeYouSoon Game Club » Honkai Star Rail players are demanding one farming feature from Genshin Impact How Honkai Star Rail players want Genshin Impact's crafting bonus system to solve frustrating material farming