Understanding the Lucas Riggs controversy in Call of Duty Vanguard and its impact on gaming representation
The Lucas Riggs Character and Historical Inspiration
As Call of Duty Vanguard prepared for launch, an unexpected controversy emerged surrounding one of its central characters that sparked significant discussion within the gaming community.
The introduction of Lucas Riggs as one of Vanguard’s four main protagonists generated immediate attention, particularly regarding the character’s historical foundations and national identity.
Developers at Sledgehammer Games crafted Riggs as an Australian soldier, drawing direct inspiration from Charles Upham, the only combat soldier in history to receive two Victoria Crosses – the British Commonwealth’s highest military honor for valor.
Upham’s military career serves as a benchmark for extraordinary courage in warfare.
His documented heroic actions include single-handedly assaulting German machine gun positions and executing daring rescue missions for wounded comrades while under intense enemy fire.
The development team positioned Riggs alongside three other international protagonists: Russian sniper Polina Petrova, British paratrooper Arthur Kingsley, and American pilot Wade Jackson, creating a diverse multinational squad for the campaign narrative.
However, the creative decision to base an Australian character on a New Zealand war hero created immediate tension within the gaming community and beyond.
Community Backlash and Cultural Response
The gaming community response was swift and vocal across multiple platforms, with New Zealand players expressing their disappointment and frustration.
One player identified as Hush1der expressed strong sentiments, stating, “The decision to portray Lucas Riggs as Australian rather than honoring Charles Upham’s actual heritage feels like disrespect toward fans in both Australia and New Zealand,” while other community members adopted sarcastic tones, commenting: “Eager to experience the Lucas Riggs narrative, inspired by that remarkable AUSTRALIAN soldier Charles Upham.”
Black Ops 7 devs address Call of Duty’s controversial skins
Battlefield 6 fans beg DICE to keep CoD’s wacky crossover skins out of the game
Call of Duty 2027 set to be first new COD franchise in several years
Another Reddit user characterized the situation as “disrespectful toward New Zealand’s identity and toward gamers who may not understand the distinction between the two nations.”
CommanderNZ, representing many New Zealand gamers, shared their perspective: “As someone who regularly attends ANZAC memorial services and values our military heritage, this creative choice is deeply disappointing. I hope the development team addresses this oversight before the official release.”
🇬🇧 Sergeant Arthur Kingsley
🇷🇺 Lieutenant Polina Petrova
🇺🇸 Lieutenant Wade Jackson
🇦🇺 Second Lieutenant Lucas Riggs pic.twitter.com/cTeJmkxEcs
— Call of Duty ANZ (@CallofDuty_ANZ) August 24, 2021
New Zealand media outlets amplified the community’s concerns through critical coverage.
Newshub publication emphasized: “Charles Upham’s historical importance cannot be minimized. His achievement of two Victoria Crosses remains unique in military history and represents a significant point of national pride for New Zealand.
“This creative choice parallels reimagining Sir Edmund Hillary, Lorde, or Jonah Lomu as Australian figures. The decision feels disrespectful, representing either cultural ignorance or intentional disregard for national identity.”
Developer Response and Gaming Industry Context
Sledgehammer Games addressed the growing controversy through official statements, though their response indicated limited flexibility for immediate changes.
The development team provided commentary to various gaming publications, including Dexerto, regarding the Newshub coverage and community feedback.
“Our campaign characters draw substantial inspiration from actual historical soldiers,” explained the Call of Duty Vanguard development team. “For Lucas Riggs, we incorporated numerous elements from Charles Upham’s remarkable military career, which exemplified the courage demonstrated by Commonwealth forces throughout the North African campaigns.”
This official position suggests the developers recognized community concerns but faced practical limitations in implementing substantial narrative modifications so close to launch.
From an Australian gaming journalist’s perspective, positive national representation in entertainment media remains valuable and appreciated.
However, the question arises whether such representation should come at the cost of accurately portraying neighboring nations’ historical figures.
Australia possesses its own distinguished military heritage, with 96 soldiers receiving Victoria Cross awards throughout history. Twenty of these honors were granted for actions across multiple World War II theaters, spanning from Egyptian campaigns to New Guinea operations.
The development team had numerous authentic Australian heroes available for character inspiration.
Alternatively, maintaining Lucas Riggs’ New Zealand heritage would have preserved historical accuracy while honoring the unique accomplishment of Charles Upham.
Broader Implications for Game Development
The Lucas Riggs situation illustrates several critical considerations for modern game development regarding historical representation and cultural sensitivity.
Cultural Research Protocols: Development teams benefit from implementing thorough cultural research processes when basing characters on real historical figures. Engaging cultural consultants during pre-production can prevent such controversies.
Player Expectation Management: Modern gamers increasingly expect authentic representation and historical accuracy, particularly when games incorporate real-world events and figures. Transparency about creative liberties helps manage expectations.
Post-Release Adaptation: While pre-launch changes may be challenging, developers can consider post-release content updates or narrative expansions that address community feedback and correct historical inaccuracies.
Community Communication Strategies: Establishing clear communication channels for cultural feedback allows developers to address concerns proactively rather than reactively.
The gaming industry continues evolving its approach to cultural representation, with the Vanguard controversy serving as another learning opportunity for developers worldwide.
No reproduction without permission：SeeYouSoon Game Club » CoD Vanguard has turned Kiwi war hero into Aussie character and players are furious Understanding the Lucas Riggs controversy in Call of Duty Vanguard and its impact on gaming representation