Strategic guide for choosing the best starter Pokémon in Brilliant Diamond & Shining Pearl with battle insights
Introduction: The Starter Pokémon Decision
Selecting your first Pokémon companion in Brilliant Diamond & Shining Pearl represents one of the most impactful decisions shaping your entire Sinnoh adventure. This choice influences your early game strategy, team composition planning, and overall battle effectiveness throughout your journey.
The initial Pokémon selection determines your foundational battling approach and type coverage strategy from the very beginning of your trainer career. Turtwig, Piplup, and Chimchar each offer distinct advantages that cater to different playstyles and strategic preferences.
While these remakes preserve the classic Sinnoh experience from the original 2006 Nintendo DS games, the enhanced visual presentation with polished 3D environments and charming chibi character models creates a fresh experience for both veteran trainers and newcomers alike. The quality-of-life improvements and updated features make revisiting this beloved region feel completely revitalized.
Before embarking on your quest to conquer the Pokémon League and complete the Sinnoh Pokédex, carefully evaluating each starter’s strengths, evolution paths, and long-term battle viability will ensure you begin your adventure with optimal strategic positioning.
Starter Pokémon Deep Analysis
Each starter Pokémon brings unique type combinations and evolutionary advantages to your team. Understanding their progression paths and battle specializations will help you make an informed decision aligned with your preferred battling approach.
Turtwig – The Grounded Grass-Type: Beginning as a pure Grass-type, Turtwig evolves into Grotle at level 18 and ultimately becomes Torterra at level 32, gaining the Ground typing. This dual-type combination provides excellent defensive coverage but creates a 4x weakness to Ice-type moves. Torterra’s high HP and Attack stats make it a formidable physical attacker with access to powerful moves like Wood Hammer and Earthquake.
Chimchar – The Fiery Fighter: Starting as a pure Fire-type, Chimchar evolves into Monferno at level 14, gaining Fighting-type attributes, and reaches its final form as Infernape at level 36. This Fire/Fighting combination offers outstanding offensive coverage against numerous types. Infernape’s balanced Attack and Special Attack stats allow for versatile move sets incorporating both physical and special attacks.
Piplup – The Aquatic Royalty: As a pure Water-type initially, Piplup evolves into Prinplup at level 16 and achieves its final evolution as Empoleon at level 36, gaining the Steel typing. This Water/Steel combination provides exceptional defensive utility with only three weaknesses (Fighting, Ground, Electric). Empoleon’s high Special Attack and respectable defenses make it a durable special attacker.
- Chimchar evolves earliest at level 14
- All starters reach final evolution between levels 32-36
- Secondary typings significantly impact battle effectiveness
Gym Battle Performance Analysis
Your starter’s performance against Sinnoh’s Gym Leaders significantly impacts your progression speed and resource management throughout the game. Strategic type advantages can determine battle outcomes with minimal item consumption.
Early Gym Dominance: Against Oreburgh City’s Gym Leader Roark and his Rock-type team, both Piplup and Turtwig possess immediate type superiority. Water and Grass moves deal double damage against Rock-types, allowing for straightforward victories. Chimchar requires strategic patience, needing evolution to Monferno and learning Mach Punch to effectively counter Rock-types.
Mid-Game Advantage: Chimchar’s evolution into Monferno before the second gym provides significant tactical benefits against Eterna City’s Grass-type specialist Gardenia. Fire-type moves devastate her Turtwig and other Grass-types, while Fighting-type coverage handles secondary Normal-types. This early dual-typing gives Chimchar superior type coverage during the critical mid-game progression.
Elite Four and Champion Performance: Chimchar’s final evolution into Infernape delivers exceptional performance against the Pokémon League’s toughest challenges. The Fire/Fighting typing proves devastating against multiple Elite Four members and the Champion’s team composition, particularly against Grass and Steel-type opponents. This late-game dominance often determines championship victory with reduced team-building requirements.
Strategic Considerations and Team Building
Beyond individual starter strengths, considering how your choice integrates with your overall team composition reveals the complete strategic picture. Each starter creates different team-building requirements and opportunity costs.
Type Coverage Planning: Selecting Turtwig necessitates acquiring strong Fire and Ice-type counters early. Choosing Piplup requires finding reliable Electric and Grass-type resistance. Opting for Chimchar demands Water and Ground-type coverage solutions. Understanding these requirements from the start enables proactive team construction rather than reactive problem-solving.
Advanced Training Strategies: For competitive-minded trainers, EV training considerations should influence starter selection. Turtwig/Torterra excels in HP and Attack investment, Chimchar/Infernape benefits from Speed and mixed attacking stats, while Piplup/Empoleon thrives with Special Attack and defensive investment. Planning EV training from the beginning maximizes battle potential.
Ultimate Verdict: While personal preference ultimately guides the ideal starter choice, Chimchar provides the most consistent battle performance throughout the entire Sinnoh journey. Its early evolution timeline, superior type coverage against major gym leaders, and exceptional Elite Four performance establish it as the strategically optimal selection for most playthroughs.
Your starter Pokémon becomes your trusted partner throughout the Sinnoh region exploration. Whether you prioritize early-game ease, mid-game dominance, or late-game supremacy should guide your final decision.
For comprehensive Brilliant Diamond & Shining Pearl gameplay assistance, additional strategic resources include:
All Rare Candy locations | Where to find Munchlax | Hardest Pokemon to catch in the Sinnoh region | Where to find Cresselia | How to find Heatran | How to get the National Pokedex
No reproduction without permission：SeeYouSoon Game Club » Best starter to pick in Pokemon Brilliant Diamond & Shining Pearl Strategic guide for choosing the best starter Pokémon in Brilliant Diamond & Shining Pearl with battle insights