Discover how to potentially keep good companions during evil playthroughs and understand the risks of using exploits
The Companion Dilemma in Evil Playthroughs
Baldur’s Gate 3 presents players with significant moral choices that directly impact companion availability, particularly when pursuing evil-aligned story paths.
The game’s branching narrative system creates genuine consequences for player decisions, especially evident when recruiting certain companions. This creates a fundamental tension for players who want to experience multiple storylines without committing fully to a single moral alignment.
When pursuing Minthara’s recruitment path, players must participate in the Emerald Grove raid—an action that directly conflicts with the moral codes of companions Karlach and Wyll. These characters have strong personal convictions against such violent actions and will permanently leave the party if players proceed with the goblin assault.
Many players find themselves wanting to explore Minthara’s unique story content while maintaining relationships with their existing companions, creating demand for workarounds that bypass the game’s intended moral consequences.
The Controversial Companion Exploit Method
A specific sequence discovered by the community attempts to circumvent companion departure through strategic use of game mechanics.
The method, originally shared by Reddit user Thor_HS, involves a multi-step process that exploits the game’s companion death and resurrection systems. Players must first recruit both Karlach and Wyll normally, ensuring they’re active members of the camp.
The critical steps involve: strategically eliminating both companions while they’re at camp, proceeding with the Emerald Grove raid to recruit Minthara, completing the goblin celebration event, and then using resurrection scrolls or spells to bring the fallen companions back to life.
According to reports, resurrected companions will question events at the grove but won’t automatically leave the party, allowing players to maintain access to their storylines and abilities while having Minthara available.
However, this approach clearly subverts the game’s intended narrative flow and relies on what appears to be an oversight in how the game tracks companion status during critical story events.
Risks and Technical Limitations
Using this exploit carries significant risks that could impact your save file’s long-term stability and enjoyment.
The most substantial concern involves future game patches. Larian Studios regularly updates Baldur’s Gate 3 to fix bugs and maintain narrative consistency. This particular exploit appears to be an unintended loophole that will likely be addressed in future updates.
Community experiences reveal inconsistent results across different playthroughs. Some players report success with both companions, while others find that Wyll immediately departs when combat initiates, despite the resurrection. This inconsistency suggests the exploit may depend on specific game states or sequencing.
Potential game-breaking issues include: companions permanently disappearing after future patches, broken dialogue trees, conflicting quest triggers, and narrative inconsistencies that could ruin immersion. Players have reported strange behaviors like companion bodies remaining in camp despite resurrection or departure notifications appearing incorrectly.
The timing of your playthrough matters significantly—methods that worked several weeks ago may no longer function due to recent updates, highlighting the unstable nature of relying on exploits.
Alternative Approaches and Better Solutions
Several more reliable alternatives exist for players wanting to experience multiple companion storylines without risking save file integrity.
Mod-based solutions provide the most stable approach. The Baldur’s Gate 3 modding community has developed several companion-focused mods that allow recruitment of all characters regardless of story choices. These mods are specifically designed for this purpose and typically receive updates alongside game patches.
Roleplaying alternatives include embracing the consequences of your choices and planning multiple playthroughs. This approach maintains the intended narrative experience and allows you to appreciate each companion’s story in context-appropriate scenarios. Consider dedicating specific saves to evil and good alignments separately.
Strategic sequencing can maximize content exposure—complete companion personal quests before committing to alignment-defining decisions. This allows you to experience most of their story content before making irreversible choices.
For players committed to using exploits, create multiple backup saves at critical decision points and stay informed about upcoming patches that might affect your current playthrough.
Making an Informed Decision
Understanding the risks and alternatives helps players make informed choices about their gameplay approach.
While the companion exploit offers short-term gratification, the potential long-term consequences outweigh the benefits for most players. The inconsistent results and high patch vulnerability make it unreliable for extended playthroughs.
The gaming community generally recommends embracing Baldur’s Gate 3’s consequence system as intended or using mod-based solutions for those wanting to bypass narrative restrictions. Both approaches provide more stable and satisfying experiences than relying on temporary exploits.
As Larian Studios continues supporting the game with updates and patches, players should expect such exploits to be gradually eliminated in favor of maintaining narrative integrity and gameplay balance.
No reproduction without permission：SeeYouSoon Game Club » Baldur’s Gate 3 player finds brutal way to keep good companions on evil run Discover how to potentially keep good companions during evil playthroughs and understand the risks of using exploits